BID RESULTS FOR
DESIGN-BUILD PROJECTS
 |
BRATTLEBORO IM 091-(65)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: MARCH 14, 2013 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(50 POINT SCALE) * |
AS READ COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(50 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
PCL Civil Constructors, Inc./Figg
Bridge Engineers, Inc. |
35.67 |
$59,490,000.00 |
45.39 |
81.05 |
1 |
Reed & Reed, Inc./HDR Engineering,
Inc. |
30.94 |
$54,000,000.00 |
50.00 |
80.94 |
2 |
Lane Construction Corporation/Hardesty
& Hanover, LLP |
31.00 |
$82,812,233.00 |
32.60 |
63.60 |
3 |
|
Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal: $54,000,000.00
|
Apparent Best
Value Score: 81.05 |
|
|
*For
numerical ratings of Technical Proposals, see
Memorandum RE: Technical Evaluation
Committee Results |
MILTON IM 089-3 (66)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: DECEMBER 5, 2012 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(40 POINT SCALE) * |
AS READ COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(60 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Harrison and Burrowes Bridge
Constructors, Inc. /Clough Harbour & Associates, LLP |
33.08 |
$28,277,700.00 |
49.01 |
82.09 |
3 |
Reed & Reed, Inc./Parsons Brinckerhoff,
Inc. |
32.44 |
$29,788,000.00 |
46.52 |
78.96 |
4 |
Tetra Tech Construction, Inc./URS
Corporation |
31.19 |
$23,098,000.00 |
60.00 |
91.19 |
1 |
Beck & Belluci, Inc./Hoyle Tanner
and Associates, Inc. |
30.33 |
$24,639,821.08 |
56.25 |
86.58 |
2 |
|
Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal: $23,098,000.00
|
Apparent Best
Value Score: 91.19 |
|
|
*For
numerical ratings of Technical Proposals, see
Memorandum RE: Technical Evaluation
Committee Results |
WINDSOR IM 091-1 (64)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: JULY 25, 2012 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(40 POINT SCALE) * |
AS READ COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(60 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Beck & Bellucci, Inc/Hoyle, Tanner & Associates, Inc. |
27.80 |
$19,958,016.49 |
60.00 |
87.80 |
3 |
Kubricky Construction Corp./AECOM Technical Services, Inc. |
31.30 |
$23,500,000.00 |
50.96 |
82.26 |
4 |
Tetra Tech Construction, Inc./Ryan-Biggs Associates, P.C. |
22.79 |
Non-Responsive |
The Lane Construction Corp./Jacobs Engineering Group, Inc. |
31.83 |
$20,624,561.00 |
58.06 |
89.89 |
1 |
Winterset, Inc./Parsons Brinkerhoff, Inc. |
31.09 |
$20,381,800.00 |
58.75 |
89.84 |
2 |
|
Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal: $19,958,016.49
|
Apparent Best
Value Score: 89.89 |
|
|
*For
numerical ratings of Technical Proposals, see
Memorandum RE: Technical Evaluation
Committee Results |
*
Denotes change in Amount from Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal to
Confirmed lowest Cost Proposal
|
RICHMOND STP RS 0274 (11)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: DECEMBER 16, 2010 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(40 POINT SCALE) |
AS READ COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(60 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Harrison & Burrowes, Inc./
CHA |
32.72 |
$12,900,000.00 |
60.00 |
92.72 |
1 |
J.A. McDonald, Inc./
URS Corporation |
Non-Responsive |
|
Kubricky Construction
Corporation/Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. |
31.44 |
$18,770,676.00 |
41.23 |
72.67 |
2 |
|
Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal: $12, 900,000.00
|
Apparent Best
Value Score: 92.72 |
|
|
AND |
RICHMOND STP RS 0274 (11)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: DECEMBER 16, 2010 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(40 POINT SCALE) |
CONFIRMED COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(60 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Harrison & Burrowes, Inc./
CHA |
32.72 |
$12,900,000.00 |
60.00 |
92.72 |
1 |
J.A. McDonald, Inc./
URS Corporation |
Non-Responsive |
|
Kubricky Construction
Corporation/Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. |
31.44 |
*
$18,777,676.00 |
*
41.22 |
*
72.66 |
2 |
|
Confirmed Lowest Cost Proposal: $12, 900,000.00
|
Confirmed Best Value Score:
92.72 |
|
|
AND |
RICHMOND STP RS 0274 (11)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: DECEMBER 16, 2010 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(40 POINT SCALE) |
CONFIRMED COST PROPOSAL($)
(REVISED) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(60 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Harrison & Burrowes, Inc./
CHA |
32.72 |
*$13,900,000.00 |
60.00 |
92.72 |
1 |
J.A. McDonald, Inc./
URS Corporation |
Non-Responsive |
|
Kubricky Construction
Corporation/Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. |
31.44 |
$18,777,676.00 |
41.22 |
72.66 |
2 |
|
Confirmed Lowest Cost Proposal: *$13,
900,000.00
|
Confirmed Best Value Score:
92.72 |
|
|
* Revised under
Bid Protest January 3, 2011 |
|
|
BRATTLEBORO IM 091-1 (50)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: OCTOBER 5, 2010 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(30 POINT SCALE) |
AS READ COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(70 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Beck & Bellucci, Inc./
TY Lin International |
24.90 |
$12,476,857.83 |
70.00 |
94.90 |
1 |
Harrison & Burrowes, Inc./
CHA |
26.34 |
$23,394,000.00 |
37.33 |
63.67 |
4 |
J.A. McDonald, Inc./
URS Corporation |
24.48 |
$18,888,700.00 |
46.24 |
70.72 |
3 |
Winterset, Inc./
Parsons-Brinkerhoff |
21.24 |
$16,860,278.40 |
51.80 |
73.04 |
2 |
|
Apparent Lowest Cost Proposal:
$12, 476, 857.83
|
Apparent Best Value
Score: 94.90 |
|
|
AND |
BRATTLEBORO IM 091-1 (50)
DESIGN-BUILD
BIDS OPENED: OCTOBER 5, 2010 |
|
DESIGN-BUILD TEAM |
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL SCORE
(30 POINT SCALE) |
CONFIRMED COST PROPOSAL($) |
COST PROPOSAL SCORE
(70 POINT SCALE) |
TOTAL
SCORE
(100 POINT SCALE) |
RANK |
Beck & Bellucci, Inc./
TY Lin International |
24.90 |
$12,476,857.83 |
70.00 |
94.90 |
1 |
Harrison & Burrowes, Inc./
CHA |
26.34 |
$23,394,000.00 |
37.33 |
63.67 |
4 |
J.A. McDonald, Inc./
URS Corporation |
24.48 |
$18,888,700.00 |
46.24 |
70.72 |
3 |
Winterset, Inc./
Parsons-Brinkerhoff |
21.24 |
$16,860,278.40 |
51.80 |
73.04 |
2 |
|
Confirmed Lowest Cost Proposal:
$12, 476, 857.83
|
Confirmed Best Value Score:
94.90 |
|
| |
|
Design - Build Links: |
|
D-B Home |
FAQ |
Upcoming |
Current RFQ |
Status |
Bid Results |
Awards |
|
|
|
For
questions or suggestions on our website please email us by
clicking
here. |
|
|
|
